|
There were 4 reports with possible positves recorded for this event.
View the updated prediction.
Observers: 1 D Herald,Kambah, ACT,AU 2 D Gault,Hawkesbury Heights,NSW,AU 3 H Pavlov,St Clair, NSW, Australia 4(M) S Russell,Oatlands, NSW, AU 5(M) C Wyatt,Walcha, NSW, Australia 6(P) Prediction TT14 31 Jul
Discussion:
It appears that the path has shifted slightly North of the predicted path.
The ellipse above is plotted at the best fit to the 3 chords it touches.
The chords 1-3 have been reviwed and meet the criteria of:
- the magdrop being consistent with the predicted value.
- the curve is a U shape
- the bottom has several points that are at that level.
Chord 4 has 3 possible "events". The mag drop is only about 20% of the expected value.
The one shown is that which best fits the others. This is the earliest and least like an expected dip (see below).
The Light Curve Data Base shows a maximum elongagtion of about 1.6 compared to the drwan 2.12.
The star was faint and close to Polyxena in brightness so magnitude drop was expected to be about 0.7.
All chords
were observed using integrating cameras. Chord 4 used x32 integrating, 2&3 used x 8, but chord 1 used only x4.
It is possible that a short dip of a few frames may have got lost in the longer integration.
I think this gives a lesson that where you are using an integrating type camera you should use the minimum integration setting that allows you to see the combined magnitude of the targets. Longer integrations will result in lower accuracy and possible loss of an event. You may want to consider using long integration while locating the target then wind back until you can just see the target.
I have used Occular to analyse the light curve data to try to ensure that the methodology was consistent. The results are shown below before time delays due to integration time have been applied.
The figures below shows the light curve of the occultation as interpreted by Occular.
Dave Herald x4
Dave Gault x8
Hristo Pavlov x8
Steve Russell x32
Observational Data:
Observation details for MP (595) Polyxena By Star UCA 2U12769883 On 2010-08-28 at 14:20:00.0 _______________________________ Observer Hristo Pavlov Location St Clair, NSW, Australia Longitude +150:46 Latitude -33:48 Altitude 68 m Datum WGS84 Telescope SCT including Cass and Mak Aperture 20 cm Seeing Steady Clear Timing GPS - time inserted Video with frame analysis Disappearance 14:19:41.30 Reappearance 14:19:47.76 Comments: Integ x8 Time estimated by Occular _______________________________ Observer Stephen RUSSELL Location Oatlands, NSW, AU Longitude +151:01 Latitude -33:49 Altitude 60 m Datum WGS84 Telescope Newtonian Aperture 20 cm Seeing Slight flickering Clear Timing GPS - time inserted Video with frame analysis Disappearance 14:19:45.43 Reappearance 14:19:46.84 Comments: Very short event possibly spurious Integ x32 Times from Occular analysis of first dip _______________________________ Observer Chris Wyatt Location Walcha, NSW, Australia Longitude +151:50 Latitude -31:01 Altitude 1237 m Datum WGS84 Telescope SCT including Cass and Mak Aperture 20 cm Seeing Slight flickering Thin cloud < 2 Timing Tape Recorder + time signal Visual, no PE applied Missed Comments: A difficult observation, the atmospheric scintillation made target star visible then undetectable in periods of bad seeing. Added to the visual difficulty was an inquisitive bull on the property which made me a little concerned during the minute of the occultation prediction, I think the beeper box had something to do with it. Also, thin cloud coming from the SE decided to block my view on and off through the occultation, I could not be certain of a positive result. _______________________________ Observer Dave Herald Location Kambah, ACT,AU Longitude +149:03 Latitude -35:23 Altitude 582 m Datum WGS84 Telescope SCT including Cass and Mak Aperture 35 cm Seeing Steady Clear Timing GPS - time inserted Video with frame analysis Disappearance 14:19:24.77 Reappearance 14:19:26.93 Comments: Integrating 4 frames Report prepopulated by IOTA Reporting Add-in for OW ver.1.5 Note asymmetry between D and R _______________________________ Observer Dave Gault Location Hawkesbury Heights,NSW,AU Longitude +150:38 Latitude -33:39 Altitude 286 m Datum WGS84 Telescope Newtonian Aperture 25 cm Seeing Slight flickering Clear Timing GPS - time inserted Video with frame analysis Disappearance 14:19:42.41 Reappearance 14:19:50.09 Comments: Light curve and .csv file included with this report. Integration x8 Occular D=14:19:42.456 R=49.806